Monday, November 16, 2026

Why Are Police The Way They Are?

 


Looking for something to write about I perused the CBC News site and found a decent article about Montreal police attacking what was either a majority peaceful, or totally peaceful student demonstration.  I've read CBC accounts of police vs. student confrontations before and compared to those previous stories this one was noteworthy for presenting the students' claims with as much respect as the claims of the police.

There were only about 200 protesters, calling for more financial assistance for students, more investment in education, and more attention to fixing the increasing cost-of-living crisis.  Then, suddenly, tear-gas was fired at them and police charged and began attacking demonstrators for no reason.  The reason for the brutality were the following unsubstantiated claims:

An SPVM spokesperson said that a demonstrator started to commit mischief, breaking a window and damaging a vehicle, which led to the protest being declared illegal. According to police, a firework was also fired at an officer by that one demonstrator.

"We had to deploy tear gas to spread the crowd that was aggressive at that time," said Bergeron.

Police say two people were arrested for armed assault on a police officer and another was arrested for assault on a police officer. Police noted eight incidents of mischief involving buildings or vehicles, but no citizen injuries.

To her credit, the reporter Jacqueline Newsome gives equal weight and much more than equal time to the students' accounts of police violence: 

 

Maxim Lepage, a 20-year-old psychoeducation student at the Université de Montréal, remembers the events of the protest differently.

She said she received no verbal warning from police to disperse, and only knew something had gone wrong after tear gas starting hitting the crowd.

She said that the people she was protesting with ran into a side street to flee from an advancing group of roughly 30 officers. Lepage was running away on St-Dominique Street when she turned around, and says she saw a man alone on the ground, surrounded by officers who were kicking him. 

Lepage said that when she and her friend turned around to address the officers, her friend was hit in the throat with a police riot shield. Lepage then said she was hit in the face with another officer's shield, causing her nose to begin bleeding.  

All-in-all, a good piece of journalism.  But I want to talk about why the police behave the way that they do.  They'll say that they're just enforcing the law and protecting the public and maintaining the peace.  But often that's clearly nonsense.   They're often more than happy to serve as enforcers for capitalism, even when they know that the capitalists are clearly in the wrong legally, such as when they're assaulting First Nations people protesting an illegal incursion of a fossil fuels mega-project on their lands, or when they assault peaceful anti-genocide protesters who had actually been assaulted by some IDF rapist thug at Toronto Metropolitan University. (Interestingly, I was going to find a link to that story, but such is the way of the world that shit-hole google only gave me 10 links from self-pitying, whining, murderously racist zionist filth websites.)  Since search engines won't do it, I'll tell the actual story that I saw on video.  

Some zio-nazi student group at MTU rented a classroom so that some stinking pig from the ICKF could blather about his racist ideology and his murderous sadism.  Two female anti-genocide protesters stood silently at the back of the room holding signs saying that genocide is wrong, and this caused the ICKF psychopath to lose it and he physically assaulted both of the women.  Other anti-genocide people showed up and there was a bit of a shouting match before campus security demanded that they leave and allow the zio-nazis to finish their celebration of genocide peacefully.  As they were on the platform at TMU Station, the TPS then violently arrested one of the male anti-genocide protesters for some stupid reason.

Marxists will tell you that the police are enforcers for the ruling class and it's hard to argue with that.  "Law and Order" often means laws written by the ruling class and "order" means maintaining the power of the status-quo.

But why do they do this?  I shall look for two links that maybe I'll read later.  Here I go ...

Interesting.  There are about five links from pro-police sources [or from the police themselves] about this very topic!

Continuing ...

Aw, fuck it. 

No comments: